Users who signed into third-party Web or mobile applications using their Twitter accounts might have given those applications access to their Twitter private “direct” messages without knowing it, according to Cesar Cerrudo, the chief technology officer of security consultancy firm IOActive.
The issue is the result of a flaw in Twitter’s API (application programming interface) that led to users not being properly informed about what permissions an application will have on their accounts once granted access. Cerrudo described the problem and explained how he discovered it in a blog post published Tuesday.
Applications that allow users to log in with their Twitter accounts have to be registered with Twitter at https://dev.twitter.com/apps. During registration, their developers have to declare the level of access the applications will have on people’s accounts: “read only,” “read and write” or “read, write and access to direct messages.”
When users attempt to log into such an application for the first time using their Twitter accounts, they get redirected to an authorization page on Twitter’s website that lists the permissions requested by the particular application.
Cerrudo said that he discovered the issue while he was testing an application developed by a friend that had a “read, write and access to direct messages” permission declared with Twitter.
When he first signed into the application with his Twitter account, he was redirected to an authorization page that informed him that the application would be able to read tweets from his timeline, see which users he follows, follow new users on his behalf, update his profile information and post tweets on his behalf, he said. The page clearly noted that the application would not be able to access direct messages or the account’s password.
“After viewing the displayed web page, I trusted that Twitter would not give the application access to my password and direct messages,” he wrote on the blog. “I felt that my account was safe, so I signed in and played with the application.”
The researcher noticed that the application had functionality to access and display direct messages, but the feature didn’t appear to be working. This made sense because he hadn’t been asked to grant that permission.
However, after signing in and out of the application and Twitter a few times, his direct messages started appearing in the application. When checking the list of applications authorized to interact with his Twitter account (Settings > Apps) he noticed that the application did in fact have the read, write, and access direct messages permissions.
“I realized that this was a huge security hole,” Cerrudo said.
The researcher confirmed Tuesday that he successfully reproduced the behavior several times by revoking access to the app and going through the authorization process again without being warned that the app would be able to read his private messages. The issue was reported to Twitter on Jan. 16 and was addressed in less than 24 hours, he said.
“They said the issue occurred due to complex code and incorrect assumptions and validations,” Cerrudo said in the blog post.
However, Twitter’s fix does not seem to apply retroactively. After Twitter fixed the issue, the app Cerrudo was testing that already had access to his account continued to display direct messages despite never receiving authorization from him to do so, he said.
Twitter users should check if any of the apps they authorized in the past also gained access to their direct messages without their knowledge, Cerrudo said. This can be done by reviewing their permissions on the Twitter Settings > Apps
Cerrudo decided to make this issue public because it can have serious implications and because Twitter did not issue a public advisory or announcement about it. The company should maintain a dedicated page where it can inform users about security issues, he said.
Twitter did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Latest posts by Ebenezer Obasi (see all)
- Install Windows 10/8/7 From USB Flash Drive with UEFI Support - January 31, 2019
- Windows 10’s Top 30 Tricks, Tips, and Tweaks in Pictures - January 26, 2019
- How to Use Google Docs Offline - December 22, 2018